Well said , both of you!dovecanyoncat wrote: ↑Mon May 08, 2023 10:18 pmI think it is a safe bet to presume human frailty in all matters judicative and executive. Aren't we are all flawed individuals? And further, aren't we all composite individuals whose fractions assail and dilute our better whole? In this moment I am comforted that none of us takes this lightly. It matters. It hurts because it counts. Because we judge and condemn we ourselves feel pain inseparable from the act condemned. How else do we learn?Carcassdragger wrote: ↑Mon May 08, 2023 9:54 pm I'm tired of so many on here attacking the moral character of those who happen to disagree with themselves. It's not necessary.
Texts or no texts, which we'll never see, I'm thinking the prosecutor didn't think the case was that strong and settled with JDL and his counsel because the accused may have thought the case might well have resulted in a sentence by a jury influenced by the emotion of such a heinous accusation. What happened in that stairwell may very well have been ugly with some culpability by all parties, but who knows. Point is, those who do know better than any of us, chose to settle and move on.
7 Jayden de Laura
Moderators: UAdevil, JMarkJohns
-
- Posts: 1322
- Joined: Mon Jun 09, 2014 10:08 am
- Reputation: 130
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
No Bandwagon Here! Always a Cat!
- CardiacCats97
- Posts: 1227
- Joined: Wed Aug 03, 2022 6:55 pm
- Reputation: 350
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
We don’t know, but in case you’re wondering why so few women report sexual assault, maybe we need to look at how prevalent victim-blaming is in these situations. For instance what you said right here.Carcassdragger wrote: ↑Mon May 08, 2023 9:54 pm What happened in that stairwell may very well have been ugly with some culpability by all parties, but who knows.
- EastCoastCat
- Posts: 6524
- Joined: Fri Jun 06, 2014 11:25 am
- Reputation: 1949
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
dovecanyoncat wrote: ↑Mon May 08, 2023 10:18 pmI think it is a safe bet to presume human frailty in all matters judicative and executive. Aren't we are all flawed individuals? And further, aren't we all composite individuals whose fractions assail and dilute our better whole? In this moment I am comforted that none of us takes this lightly. It matters. It hurts because it counts. Because we judge and condemn we ourselves feel pain inseparable from the act condemned. How else do we learn?Carcassdragger wrote: ↑Mon May 08, 2023 9:54 pm I'm tired of so many on here attacking the moral character of those who happen to disagree with themselves. It's not necessary.
Texts or no texts, which we'll never see, I'm thinking the prosecutor didn't think the case was that strong and settled with JDL and his counsel because the accused may have thought the case might well have resulted in a sentence by a jury influenced by the emotion of such a heinous accusation. What happened in that stairwell may very well have been ugly with some culpability by all parties, but who knows. Point is, those who do know better than any of us, chose to settle and move on.
I have plenty of flaws. Just talk to my wife...
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
Alieberman wrote: ↑Mon May 08, 2023 12:49 pmZero, nada, zilch.
I'm pretty consistent in not supporting rapists.
This isn't a grey area for me
I don't need to see their juvie records to make my ethical / moral choices.
My love of sport dies not trump my moral compass.
I have no need for mental gymnastics to make my choices.
Amen Al.
- Basketcats
- Posts: 136
- Joined: Wed Jun 04, 2014 11:08 pm
- Reputation: 58
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
Let's open up Pandora's box and peek inside.
Coach, QB and university are in the proverbial doghouse. Some have stated that they aren't going to watch the team as long as JDL is playing or on the team period. Some have stated supporting the team is supporting a bunch of rapists. Some are not willing to support the AD or watch the team until the decision is reversed.
So now the questions are...
As a fan, how do you deal with support for the team?
Do you now just deny the team exists and go on about your business during the upcoming season?
Do you focus your support on another team?
How is pulling your support for the team fair to any of the players that haven't committed a felony?
If there is a decision reversal and JDL is removed, does that instantly rectify the situation?
Does Fisch need to go now?
*Edited*
Let me answer my own questions to start that way you can all brow beat me for not being any of you.
I will not deny the existence of the team.
I will not ignore the team.
I will watch and continue to root for it.
I will never throw my support behind another team and anoint it as my primary.
The reason why I continue to throw my support behind it is because of the other 55-65 players on the team. They did nothing to deserve the disdain I feel toward the people involved in this disgusting situation. They deserve my support 100%. So I can't turn my back on them.
It took me almost half the season last year to come around and buy into what Fisch was selling. I mainly bought in because I saw a lot of what everyone who was onboard with the hire day 1 saw. It just took me a bit longer because I am a skeptic and I need to see the product before believing. Now that the product is a bit tarnished, my faith in it may be weakened, but not to the point of total collapse.
Fisch made a mistake. He didn't commit a crime, he just made a mistake. He was just doing his job, albeit sloppily. I can't completely condemn the guy for trying to make the team better. I can overlook a mistake but it needs to be corrected. JDL should, at the very least, take a backseat and not start a game. Yes, he shouldn't be on the team at all, but, unless the powers that be reverse course, there is no avoiding him being a part of it.
That's my take. Have at me. Berate away.
Coach, QB and university are in the proverbial doghouse. Some have stated that they aren't going to watch the team as long as JDL is playing or on the team period. Some have stated supporting the team is supporting a bunch of rapists. Some are not willing to support the AD or watch the team until the decision is reversed.
So now the questions are...
As a fan, how do you deal with support for the team?
Do you now just deny the team exists and go on about your business during the upcoming season?
Do you focus your support on another team?
How is pulling your support for the team fair to any of the players that haven't committed a felony?
If there is a decision reversal and JDL is removed, does that instantly rectify the situation?
Does Fisch need to go now?
*Edited*
Let me answer my own questions to start that way you can all brow beat me for not being any of you.
I will not deny the existence of the team.
I will not ignore the team.
I will watch and continue to root for it.
I will never throw my support behind another team and anoint it as my primary.
The reason why I continue to throw my support behind it is because of the other 55-65 players on the team. They did nothing to deserve the disdain I feel toward the people involved in this disgusting situation. They deserve my support 100%. So I can't turn my back on them.
It took me almost half the season last year to come around and buy into what Fisch was selling. I mainly bought in because I saw a lot of what everyone who was onboard with the hire day 1 saw. It just took me a bit longer because I am a skeptic and I need to see the product before believing. Now that the product is a bit tarnished, my faith in it may be weakened, but not to the point of total collapse.
Fisch made a mistake. He didn't commit a crime, he just made a mistake. He was just doing his job, albeit sloppily. I can't completely condemn the guy for trying to make the team better. I can overlook a mistake but it needs to be corrected. JDL should, at the very least, take a backseat and not start a game. Yes, he shouldn't be on the team at all, but, unless the powers that be reverse course, there is no avoiding him being a part of it.
That's my take. Have at me. Berate away.
Last edited by Basketcats on Tue May 09, 2023 7:50 am, edited 1 time in total.
- Alieberman
- Posts: 13803
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 11:50 am
- Reputation: 2862
- Location: I can't find my pants
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
1- I am pausing my AZ athletic support. I won't deny they exist- but I won't watch a single play. I cannot cheer for a rapist... so I cannot watch. Not going to root against the team... just will not support in any way. You won't even see me posting a single thing AZ sports related in the foreseeable future here in this forumBasketcats wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 7:23 am
So now the questions are...
As a fan, how do you deal with support for the team?
Do you now just deny the team exists and go on about your business during the upcoming season?
Do you focus your support on another team?
How is pulling your support for the team fair to any of the players that haven't committed a felony?
If there is a decision reversal and JDL is removed, does that instantly rectify the situation?
Does Fisch need to go now?
2- I find myself watching less and less sports.... I won't replace with another team / sport
3- Pulling my support is not fair to the other players. It's not their fault. But it's the only thing I can do
4- A reversal would be a great step. I don't know how it would effect me yet.
5- I don't really blame Fisch... It goes much higher than him
- CardiacCats97
- Posts: 1227
- Joined: Wed Aug 03, 2022 6:55 pm
- Reputation: 350
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
I had been planning on attending a few games (I don’t live in town) but now that’s definitely up in the air. If the only statement we are going to get from the AD is the one they put out, I’m definitely not attending and not going to any alumni functions that center around football.
As for whether it’s fair to the rest of the team, probably not, but my little one-man protest won’t affect them. They’ll still play the game and go to school. My hope though is that at least some of those players will have their own protest against playing with a rapist. I’m not hoping they quit the team or go public, but if internally they can express their displeasure maybe it will give the coaches and AD something to think about. That it’s not just fickle fans who don’t want a rapist on the Cats.
Seems like it will actually be pretty easy to ignore Arizona Football. People have been doing it for years. Now it will not just be for the on-field performance.
As for whether it’s fair to the rest of the team, probably not, but my little one-man protest won’t affect them. They’ll still play the game and go to school. My hope though is that at least some of those players will have their own protest against playing with a rapist. I’m not hoping they quit the team or go public, but if internally they can express their displeasure maybe it will give the coaches and AD something to think about. That it’s not just fickle fans who don’t want a rapist on the Cats.
Seems like it will actually be pretty easy to ignore Arizona Football. People have been doing it for years. Now it will not just be for the on-field performance.
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
https://www.google.com/amp/s/sports.yah ... 11550.html
I will just leave this here for the Lynch Brigade. These are the decisions that are made when listening to mindless fan fervor that knows jackshit about a case outside of "media reports".
I will just leave this here for the Lynch Brigade. These are the decisions that are made when listening to mindless fan fervor that knows jackshit about a case outside of "media reports".
- TheCatInTheHat
- Posts: 1305
- Joined: Sun Aug 30, 2020 12:51 pm
- Reputation: 333
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
I agree with Carcasdragger's earlier comments about people being attacked. I assume all have seen plenty of evidence elsewhere in life that nobody changes anybody's mind about much of anything. So once opinions have been fully expressed, it's pointless to continue with "but don't you see?" in all caps. True of both sides, and just because somebody made the last post, it doesn't mean it's the last word, or that they "won." It's also important to know if this board will remain viable for Arizona football fans, or if there's an intent to kill it off. There'll be no point in making posts to inform or express opinions about roster news, injuries, or performance (of the above other 55-65 players) if they're hijacked and tagged with angry views about society, comparisons of character, or criminal justice. Just my 2 cents in the middle of the maelstrom.Basketcats wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 7:23 am The reason why I continue to throw my support behind it is because of the other 55-65 players on the team. They did nothing to deserve the disdain I feel toward the people involved in this disgusting situation.
- CardiacCats97
- Posts: 1227
- Joined: Wed Aug 03, 2022 6:55 pm
- Reputation: 350
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
Huh?TheCatInTheHat wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 9:10 am It's also important to know if this board will remain viable for Arizona football fans, or if there's an intent to kill it off. There'll be no point in making posts to inform or express opinions about roster news, injuries, or performance (of the above other 55-65 players) if they're hijacked and tagged with angry views about society, comparisons of character, or criminal justice. Just my 2 cents in the middle of the maelstrom.
Has anyone talked about killing off the board or has this conversation yet leaked into other threads? I haven’t seen it, so this is a weird stretch in my opinion.
- CardiacCats97
- Posts: 1227
- Joined: Wed Aug 03, 2022 6:55 pm
- Reputation: 350
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
There are also numerous cases where rape and sexual assault were ignored or swept under the rug because the perpetrators were well known athletes or entertainers. Both are wrong and ruin lives but one happens more often than the other.CopaCat wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 9:01 am https://www.google.com/amp/s/sports.yah ... 11550.html
I will just leave this here for the Lynch Brigade. These are the decisions that are made when listening to mindless fan fervor that knows jackshit about a case outside of "media reports".
- Alieberman
- Posts: 13803
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 11:50 am
- Reputation: 2862
- Location: I can't find my pants
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
There is certainly no plan to kill off or hijack threads. This is literally the only AZ sport thread I plan on posting in.TheCatInTheHat wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 9:10 amI agree with Carcasdragger's earlier comments about people being attacked. I assume all have seen plenty of evidence elsewhere in life that nobody changes anybody's mind about much of anything. So once opinions have been fully expressed, it's pointless to continue with "but don't you see?" in all caps. True of both sides, and just because somebody made the last post, it doesn't mean it's the last word, or that they "won." It's also important to know if this board will remain viable for Arizona football fans, or if there's an intent to kill it off. There'll be no point in making posts to inform or express opinions about roster news, injuries, or performance (of the above other 55-65 players) if they're hijacked and tagged with angry views about society, comparisons of character, or criminal justice. Just my 2 cents in the middle of the maelstrom.Basketcats wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 7:23 am The reason why I continue to throw my support behind it is because of the other 55-65 players on the team. They did nothing to deserve the disdain I feel toward the people involved in this disgusting situation.
I have no illusions that my stance will effect anyone else and I'm sure if our football team does really well this year we will be more popular than ever
- Merkin
- Posts: 43290
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 10:31 am
- Reputation: 1563
- Location: UA basketball smells like....victory
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
Just to digress a bit, that story doesn't make much sense. An intoxicated person cannot give consent. A minor cannot give consent.CopaCat wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 9:01 am https://www.google.com/amp/s/sports.yah ... 11550.html
I will just leave this here for the Lynch Brigade. These are the decisions that are made when listening to mindless fan fervor that knows jackshit about a case outside of "media reports".
He and the two other players named in the suit vehemently deny any gang rape, knowledge that the girl was below California’s age of consent (18) or or whether she was intoxicated.
And the rules are even more strict for college students in CA: https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way ... sault-bill
I am with you here. After years of watching college football all day Saturday, and NFL football on Sunday, along with listening to pretty much every Detroit Tiger game on the radio, along with college basketball all winter, I only now watch UA FB and MBB. And now won't watch any FB if JDL is playing.Alieberman wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 7:36 am 2- I find myself watching less and less sports.... I won't replace with another team / sport
Nice to have my Saturdays back, since FB games go on so long.
- EastCoastCat
- Posts: 6524
- Joined: Fri Jun 06, 2014 11:25 am
- Reputation: 1949
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
Agree with this TC.TheCatInTheHat wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 9:10 amI agree with Carcasdragger's earlier comments about people being attacked. I assume all have seen plenty of evidence elsewhere in life that nobody changes anybody's mind about much of anything. So once opinions have been fully expressed, it's pointless to continue with "but don't you see?" in all caps. True of both sides, and just because somebody made the last post, it doesn't mean it's the last word, or that they "won." It's also important to know if this board will remain viable for Arizona football fans, or if there's an intent to kill it off. There'll be no point in making posts to inform or express opinions about roster news, injuries, or performance (of the above other 55-65 players) if they're hijacked and tagged with angry views about society, comparisons of character, or criminal justice. Just my 2 cents in the middle of the maelstrom.Basketcats wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 7:23 am The reason why I continue to throw my support behind it is because of the other 55-65 players on the team. They did nothing to deserve the disdain I feel toward the people involved in this disgusting situation.
I certainly understand and respect anyone that won't be supporting either the football program or Arizona athletics in general moving forward. However, it shouldn't be used as fodder to attack others that will still watch, root and comment. Otherwise, we might as well shut down BDW.
Leave it up to the Mods to decide how to proceed. I think this topic (or duplicate thread title) deserves it's place in the lower boards where people can have it.
Would hate to see a game thread for example get hijacked like...
Comment: "What a great touchdown catch by Cowing!"
Response: "Great catch if you like balls thrown by a rapist"
- Alieberman
- Posts: 13803
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 11:50 am
- Reputation: 2862
- Location: I can't find my pants
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
Totally agree with this.EastCoastCat wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 9:37 am
Leave it up to the Mods to decide how to proceed. I think this topic (or duplicate thread title) deserves it's place in the lower boards where people can have it.
Would hate to see a game thread for example get hijacked like...
Comment: "What a great touchdown catch by Cowing!"
Response: "Great catch if you like balls thrown by a rapist"
Which is why a few days earlier I had posted that we are going to need a couple new mods. (An easy job- just need a couple level headed people to keep the peace from time to time)
Most of our current Mods are no longer active and I will no longer be active on the AZ sports threads.
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
If the University kicks JDL off the team, it's doing so with limited information. We have the allegation of what happened based on the civil suit filings. And those allegations are awful. And we have the fact JDL and Latu plead guilty to a juvenile offense. But what we don't have is a lot more than that.
We have no statements from the boys in their defense other than Latu's lawyer stating the incident was consensual.
We don't know how the victim's version of the story would have held up to cross examination of a defense lawyer. Even if the case went to trial, the testimony would be sealed as part of the case.
We haven't heard from the victim or her family if they believe JDL and Latu getting no jail time and only punishment being writing an apology letter is justice served, or if the victim and family believe this was a travesty.
We also don't know how the victim and her family feel about JDL being on scholarship at Arizona and Latu being on scholarship at Wisconsin. A question that wouldn't be fair to ask now, because the victim and family have a financial reason for these kids to succeed.
If you think this is enough to kick JDL off the team, think of the precedent it sets by the University. The University has to make policies that are fair and equitable for all 38,000+ students. Kick JDL off the team and the next time there is an accusation that an athlete has a juvie rape conviction, what should the school do? There may be even less information available, and if no civil case filed, no recourse at all for the University to ascertain the truth.
This is the reason why Wisconsin and Arizona both came to the same resolution. Which is cases adjudicated in juvie court before a kid became a student is off limits for the school to take any action. If morality is derived from the truth, how can you make a moral judgement when much of the truth is hidden, and will legally remain hidden, possibly in perpetuity? And how is a university supposed to make policy that is fair and equitable to all students, unless that policy is the one both Wisconsin and Arizona chose?
We have no statements from the boys in their defense other than Latu's lawyer stating the incident was consensual.
We don't know how the victim's version of the story would have held up to cross examination of a defense lawyer. Even if the case went to trial, the testimony would be sealed as part of the case.
We haven't heard from the victim or her family if they believe JDL and Latu getting no jail time and only punishment being writing an apology letter is justice served, or if the victim and family believe this was a travesty.
We also don't know how the victim and her family feel about JDL being on scholarship at Arizona and Latu being on scholarship at Wisconsin. A question that wouldn't be fair to ask now, because the victim and family have a financial reason for these kids to succeed.
If you think this is enough to kick JDL off the team, think of the precedent it sets by the University. The University has to make policies that are fair and equitable for all 38,000+ students. Kick JDL off the team and the next time there is an accusation that an athlete has a juvie rape conviction, what should the school do? There may be even less information available, and if no civil case filed, no recourse at all for the University to ascertain the truth.
This is the reason why Wisconsin and Arizona both came to the same resolution. Which is cases adjudicated in juvie court before a kid became a student is off limits for the school to take any action. If morality is derived from the truth, how can you make a moral judgement when much of the truth is hidden, and will legally remain hidden, possibly in perpetuity? And how is a university supposed to make policy that is fair and equitable to all students, unless that policy is the one both Wisconsin and Arizona chose?
- Merkin
- Posts: 43290
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 10:31 am
- Reputation: 1563
- Location: UA basketball smells like....victory
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
I admit I haven't read every post, especially those by azcatfan2 but I don't care if anyone else watches JDL play, I am just not going to. Don't recall any posts telling other people to quit watching either. It's just a personal matter.EastCoastCat wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 9:37 am However, it shouldn't be used as fodder to attack others that will still watch, root and comment. Otherwise, we might as well shut down BDW.
So no FB RAP for me if there is going to be such a thing, but I will still play Greg's undefeated countdown game since the UA won't be involved.
I am yet not totally convinced JDL will play. There may be legal issues with pulling his scholie, but there is no reason whatsoever they have to play him.
If that was Fisch, that would be what I would do. Just name Fifita the starter, he has more potential anyway.
- EastCoastCat
- Posts: 6524
- Joined: Fri Jun 06, 2014 11:25 am
- Reputation: 1949
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
I haven't heard it specifically called out not to watch but there have been comments such as "if you want to support RapistU, go right ahead" so thought it would be important for us to establish the proper guardrails before the season starts.Merkin wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 10:00 amDon't recall any posts telling other people to quit watching either. It's just a personal matter.EastCoastCat wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 9:37 am However, it shouldn't be used as fodder to attack others that will still watch, root and comment. Otherwise, we might as well shut down BDW.
- Merkin
- Posts: 43290
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 10:31 am
- Reputation: 1563
- Location: UA basketball smells like....victory
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
Excellent point.EastCoastCat wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 10:15 am I haven't heard it specifically called out not to watch but there have been comments such as "if you want to support RapistU, go right ahead" so thought it would be important for us to establish the proper guardrails before the season starts.
And I will certainly support UA FB if they bench JDL, but like Ari, will stay out of the football forums until as long as he plays.
- CardiacCats97
- Posts: 1227
- Joined: Wed Aug 03, 2022 6:55 pm
- Reputation: 350
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
Where did you see that?EastCoastCat wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 10:15 amI haven't heard it specifically called out not to watch but there have been comments such as "if you want to support RapistU, go right ahead" so thought it would be important for us to establish the proper guardrails before the season starts.Merkin wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 10:00 amDon't recall any posts telling other people to quit watching either. It's just a personal matter.EastCoastCat wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 9:37 am However, it shouldn't be used as fodder to attack others that will still watch, root and comment. Otherwise, we might as well shut down BDW.
- EastCoastCat
- Posts: 6524
- Joined: Fri Jun 06, 2014 11:25 am
- Reputation: 1949
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
For the love...CardiacCats97 wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 10:55 amWhere did you see that?EastCoastCat wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 10:15 amI haven't heard it specifically called out not to watch but there have been comments such as "if you want to support RapistU, go right ahead" so thought it would be important for us to establish the proper guardrails before the season starts.Merkin wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 10:00 amDon't recall any posts telling other people to quit watching either. It's just a personal matter.EastCoastCat wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 9:37 am However, it shouldn't be used as fodder to attack others that will still watch, root and comment. Otherwise, we might as well shut down BDW.
I don't really want to call anyone out - there was one quote "at worst we are RapistU" - so I'm assuming you can understand the implications that could be made against anyone who continues to support JDL, the football program or the athletic department in general moving forward. Emotions are pretty high on this topic - and rightfully so
So let me re-phrase my point so it's clear - let's make sure we separate the football-related thread discussions with this topic. That's why we have upper and lower boards.
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
What about the other sports forums (basketball, etc.) since he was cleared to stay by the athletic department?Merkin wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 10:26 amExcellent point.EastCoastCat wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 10:15 am I haven't heard it specifically called out not to watch but there have been comments such as "if you want to support RapistU, go right ahead" so thought it would be important for us to establish the proper guardrails before the season starts.
And I will certainly support UA FB if they bench JDL, but like Ari, will stay out of the football forums until as long as he plays.
- CardiacCats97
- Posts: 1227
- Joined: Wed Aug 03, 2022 6:55 pm
- Reputation: 350
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
I just wanted to know if anyone had said that. Good to know that no one has, even though you said that that comment existed.EastCoastCat wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 11:20 amFor the love...CardiacCats97 wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 10:55 amWhere did you see that?EastCoastCat wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 10:15 amI haven't heard it specifically called out not to watch but there have been comments such as "if you want to support RapistU, go right ahead" so thought it would be important for us to establish the proper guardrails before the season starts.Merkin wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 10:00 amDon't recall any posts telling other people to quit watching either. It's just a personal matter.EastCoastCat wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 9:37 am However, it shouldn't be used as fodder to attack others that will still watch, root and comment. Otherwise, we might as well shut down BDW.
I don't really want to call anyone out - there was one quote "at worst we are RapistU" - so I'm assuming you can understand the implications that could be made against anyone who continues to support JDL, the football program or the athletic department in general moving forward. Emotions are pretty high on this topic - and rightfully so
So let me re-phrase my point so it's clear - let's make sure we separate the football-related thread discussions with this topic. That's why we have upper and lower boards.
Seems like predictions of some war within the fanbase spilling over into multiple threads are premature at best. I haven’t seen anyone say anything remotely like what you posted. All I’ve seen are people saying that they personally won’t watch or support.
- Alieberman
- Posts: 13803
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 11:50 am
- Reputation: 2862
- Location: I can't find my pants
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
I totally get what ECC is saying. He didn't accuse anyone of anything.
I have made my choices and I am not here to to judge anyone else's in regard to how they deal with the info they have on this.
I have made my choices and I am not here to to judge anyone else's in regard to how they deal with the info they have on this.
- EastCoastCat
- Posts: 6524
- Joined: Fri Jun 06, 2014 11:25 am
- Reputation: 1949
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
If it makes you feel better that it's not the exact words go for it. What do you think this phrase implies?CardiacCats97 wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 11:43 amI just wanted to know if anyone had said that. Good to know that no one has, even though you said that that comment existed.EastCoastCat wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 11:20 amFor the love...CardiacCats97 wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 10:55 amWhere did you see that?EastCoastCat wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 10:15 amI haven't heard it specifically called out not to watch but there have been comments such as "if you want to support RapistU, go right ahead" so thought it would be important for us to establish the proper guardrails before the season starts.
I don't really want to call anyone out - there was one quote "at worst we are RapistU" - so I'm assuming you can understand the implications that could be made against anyone who continues to support JDL, the football program or the athletic department in general moving forward. Emotions are pretty high on this topic - and rightfully so
So let me re-phrase my point so it's clear - let's make sure we separate the football-related thread discussions with this topic. That's why we have upper and lower boards.
Seems like predictions of some war within the fanbase spilling over into multiple threads are premature at best. I haven’t seen anyone say anything remotely like what you posted. All I’ve seen are people saying that they personally won’t watch or support.
"If you find it necessary to justify this so you can root for your team and Bear Down… I just hope you can sleep well at night"
Try to stick to the point I was trying to make. I am not predicting anything nor do I know for a fact that a "war will break out". The mods should just be prepared that's all. Make sense?
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
An outsider never knows the inner workings on what went down in a Rape/Sexual Assault case so that is why holding an opinion either way is questionable. A plea agreement is not always tantamount to actual guilt. Especially one drawn up for 2 17 year olds accused of a violent rape. Honestly I still can't get over the punishment being an apology for something like that......unless there is more to the story.CardiacCats97 wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 9:30 amThere are also numerous cases where rape and sexual assault were ignored or swept under the rug because the perpetrators were well known athletes or entertainers. Both are wrong and ruin lives but one happens more often than the other.CopaCat wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 9:01 am https://www.google.com/amp/s/sports.yah ... 11550.html
I will just leave this here for the Lynch Brigade. These are the decisions that are made when listening to mindless fan fervor that knows jackshit about a case outside of "media reports".
So in conclusion, maybe JDL should be gone, maybe he shouldn't. Those that seem so sure are definitely working with their inner "Me Too" politics on full display.
- CardiacCats97
- Posts: 1227
- Joined: Wed Aug 03, 2022 6:55 pm
- Reputation: 350
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
Initially I thought that you had seen that quote on Twitter/social media because I hadn’t remembered anyone saying that here.EastCoastCat wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 12:06 pmIf it makes you feel better that it's not the exact words go for it. What do you think this phrase implies?CardiacCats97 wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 11:43 amI just wanted to know if anyone had said that. Good to know that no one has, even though you said that that comment existed.EastCoastCat wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 11:20 amFor the love...CardiacCats97 wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 10:55 amWhere did you see that?EastCoastCat wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 10:15 am
I haven't heard it specifically called out not to watch but there have been comments such as "if you want to support RapistU, go right ahead" so thought it would be important for us to establish the proper guardrails before the season starts.
I don't really want to call anyone out - there was one quote "at worst we are RapistU" - so I'm assuming you can understand the implications that could be made against anyone who continues to support JDL, the football program or the athletic department in general moving forward. Emotions are pretty high on this topic - and rightfully so
So let me re-phrase my point so it's clear - let's make sure we separate the football-related thread discussions with this topic. That's why we have upper and lower boards.
Seems like predictions of some war within the fanbase spilling over into multiple threads are premature at best. I haven’t seen anyone say anything remotely like what you posted. All I’ve seen are people saying that they personally won’t watch or support.
"If you find it necessary to justify this so you can root for your team and Bear Down… I just hope you can sleep well at night"
Try to stick to the point I was trying to make. I am not predicting anything nor do I know for a fact that a "war will break out". The mods should just be prepared that's all. Make sense?
I hope nobody wants to see this leaking out into other threads, or for politics to derail sports discussions. For instance, I would hope the posters who blame on-field results on “bad fans” not supporting the team won’t be blaming a subpar JDL performance on people “trying to run him out of town”.
- wyo-cat
- Posts: 7788
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 6:27 pm
- Reputation: 506
- Location: Dusty Mexican Borderlands
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
We’ve had a pretty good run.
For a quirky independent board/community. I didn’t think it would make it this far.
For a quirky independent board/community. I didn’t think it would make it this far.
- Merkin
- Posts: 43290
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 10:31 am
- Reputation: 1563
- Location: UA basketball smells like....victory
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
I will still watch MBB. If you look at the Pitt's situation on him being benched, that was on Sean Miller. If JDL plays, that's on Fisch. If Fisch benches JDL, I will watch football.
Not a lawyer, but if he plead guilty that would make him guilty. Just as the Supreme Court declared if that if you accept a pardon, you are admitting guilt.
But have innocent people plead guilty, most certainly. The DA can stack the evidence pretty well.
My uneducated guess was why there was no jail time was that the victim was raped in October, and did not make a police report until December, and the DA had to get what he could get. A rape kit shortly after the assault would have changed the results I imagine.
Last edited by Merkin on Tue May 09, 2023 1:25 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- Alieberman
- Posts: 13803
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 11:50 am
- Reputation: 2862
- Location: I can't find my pants
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
We can guess why the punishment was only a written apology and no jail time when the ages of the kids, and nature of the crime meant they could have been charged as adults and facing a maximum penalty of 15 years. But all we can do is speculate. I think we would all want to know the reason why the punishment was so light, and perhaps, if had that information, we would change our judgement. And this could go either way. If the full truth came out and put JDL in a worse light, and he got off easy because he was a local football star, I'd move into the camp of kicking him off the team.
But it's the nature of juvie cases that the full truth will never be known. The truth hides behind the fact the law keeps these cases closed most of the time. Yes, the University may be hiding behind this law as well by keeping JDL, but no law is perfect, and sometimes we have to accept things we don't like, because the alternative is worse. For example, allowing racists to have their freedom of speech protected by the law, no matter how revolting said speech may be.
But it's the nature of juvie cases that the full truth will never be known. The truth hides behind the fact the law keeps these cases closed most of the time. Yes, the University may be hiding behind this law as well by keeping JDL, but no law is perfect, and sometimes we have to accept things we don't like, because the alternative is worse. For example, allowing racists to have their freedom of speech protected by the law, no matter how revolting said speech may be.
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
The reports have indicated that de Laura texted the victim within days, acknowledging that he did it and apologizing. That text was supposedly evidence presented to law enforcement. The civil settlement contained an acknowlodgment and an apology.
There should be no doubt the he was guilty of second degree sexual assault at this point.
Anger at the perpetrator is an obvious response when learning of these kinds of crimes - whether in real time, or after-the-fact. And there are two types of anger that exist:
In this case, both the criminal justice and civil justice systems have done their jobs.
However, we have no knowledge of the victim's perspective, her "impact(s), and/or her sense of "justice" for de Laura.
Neither do we have any insight into de Laura's accounting for his behavior or rehabilitation, remorse, etc.
The fact also is that de Laura has had a high profile position at two universities since then. At the U of A he has, obviously had some significant relationships with coaches and others in the university community. The disclosure of the crime has, obviously, needed to be addressed with those people, and some decision made to what the most appropriate course of action should be.
So, I think the questions that are being addressed herein are what further consequences are appropriate, Should they be retributive? Should they be "forward-facing"?
Personally I don't think there is a "correct" answer. I do think that some consideration of rehabilitation should be taken into account for de Laura. I think those at the university should be making those judgments. But, not just the FB coaching staff, as the judgment should not be compromised by his talent or FB value. He should be judged as any member of a sports team, or even another scholarship recipient would be.
I don't follow football much at all in the off-season, and am, to be honest, a fair-weather fan during the season. My own choice can therefore be delayed for a while.
I absolutely respect each fan/poster's choices in this regards as well.
There should be no doubt the he was guilty of second degree sexual assault at this point.
Anger at the perpetrator is an obvious response when learning of these kinds of crimes - whether in real time, or after-the-fact. And there are two types of anger that exist:
- Anger that is "forward facing", rightfully seeking redress of a wrong, and
- Anger that is purely retributive, seeking to inflict pain on the offender
In this case, both the criminal justice and civil justice systems have done their jobs.
However, we have no knowledge of the victim's perspective, her "impact(s), and/or her sense of "justice" for de Laura.
Neither do we have any insight into de Laura's accounting for his behavior or rehabilitation, remorse, etc.
The fact also is that de Laura has had a high profile position at two universities since then. At the U of A he has, obviously had some significant relationships with coaches and others in the university community. The disclosure of the crime has, obviously, needed to be addressed with those people, and some decision made to what the most appropriate course of action should be.
So, I think the questions that are being addressed herein are what further consequences are appropriate, Should they be retributive? Should they be "forward-facing"?
Personally I don't think there is a "correct" answer. I do think that some consideration of rehabilitation should be taken into account for de Laura. I think those at the university should be making those judgments. But, not just the FB coaching staff, as the judgment should not be compromised by his talent or FB value. He should be judged as any member of a sports team, or even another scholarship recipient would be.
I don't follow football much at all in the off-season, and am, to be honest, a fair-weather fan during the season. My own choice can therefore be delayed for a while.
I absolutely respect each fan/poster's choices in this regards as well.
“If you have the choice between humble and cocky, go with cocky. There's always time to be humble later, once you've been proven horrendously, irrevocably wrong.”
― Kinky Friedman
― Kinky Friedman
- Merkin
- Posts: 43290
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 10:31 am
- Reputation: 1563
- Location: UA basketball smells like....victory
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
And to be honest too, I find football a lot more boring than basketball and started losing interest in UA FB during the later RichRod years.
NFL football has 11 minutes of actual action, and over 100 commercials. https://qz.com/150577/an-average-nfl-ga ... es-of-play
- CardiacCats97
- Posts: 1227
- Joined: Wed Aug 03, 2022 6:55 pm
- Reputation: 350
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
I don’t think Heeke can find his penis with both hands. I think he’s a rubber stamp.
From what we know, Fisch knew in the Fall that there was a civil suit. If he didn’t bother to find out the details, that’s bad. If he did find out the details and still played JDL, that’s worse. Even if the AD determined they had to honor his scholarship, Fisch didn’t have to play him.
From what we know, Fisch knew in the Fall that there was a civil suit. If he didn’t bother to find out the details, that’s bad. If he did find out the details and still played JDL, that’s worse. Even if the AD determined they had to honor his scholarship, Fisch didn’t have to play him.
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
Regardless of what an individual fan chooses to do regarding following the cats after this, I think a football coach should any and all of his individual players to achieve the best possible football outcomes....CardiacCats97 wrote: ↑Tue May 09, 2023 3:08 pm I don’t think Heeke can find his penis with both hands. I think he’s a rubber stamp.
From what we know, Fisch knew in the Fall that there was a civil suit. If he didn’t bother to find out the details, that’s bad. If he did find out the details and still played JDL, that’s worse. Even if the AD determined they had to honor his scholarship, Fisch didn’t have to play him.
I'm respecting your choices on this matter.
I'm respecting the coach's choices here.
I'm respecting Heeke's choices.
I'm respecting Robbins' choices. (See my long post above.)
“If you have the choice between humble and cocky, go with cocky. There's always time to be humble later, once you've been proven horrendously, irrevocably wrong.”
― Kinky Friedman
― Kinky Friedman
- Alieberman
- Posts: 13803
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 11:50 am
- Reputation: 2862
- Location: I can't find my pants
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
I remember a time when there were a lot of people who complained that we didn't have a President who cared about athletics.
Robbins loves him his sports
Robbins loves him his sports
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
Good video cast of the reporter in Hawaii who broke the story answering questions
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Z-VvZY_rH ... FIAQ%3D%3D
I found it interesting our basketball transfer recruit was rolling with those the guys the night of the shooting
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Z-VvZY_rH ... FIAQ%3D%3D
I found it interesting our basketball transfer recruit was rolling with those the guys the night of the shooting
Waiting at the Rose Bowl patiently for the cats to arrive
"I've got a fever, and the only prescription is more wildcat sports"
2019 BDW Survivor Pool Champion
"I've got a fever, and the only prescription is more wildcat sports"
2019 BDW Survivor Pool Champion
-
- Posts: 1731
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 11:01 pm
- Reputation: 340
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
Is it wrong to root for Arizona Football while also hoping the QB gets severely injured?
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
Yes. WTF!!!gronk4heisman wrote: ↑Wed May 10, 2023 9:29 am Is it wrong to root for Arizona Football while also hoping the QB gets severely injured?
“If you have the choice between humble and cocky, go with cocky. There's always time to be humble later, once you've been proven horrendously, irrevocably wrong.”
― Kinky Friedman
― Kinky Friedman
- EastCoastCat
- Posts: 6524
- Joined: Fri Jun 06, 2014 11:25 am
- Reputation: 1949
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
Oh boy...
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
Just a guess, but how the JDL Lawyer statement reads, JDL and Latu were charged with the Class 2 assault, but plead guilty to a lesser charge. What they actually plead to? it is sealed, and we may never know.
- CardiacCats97
- Posts: 1227
- Joined: Wed Aug 03, 2022 6:55 pm
- Reputation: 350
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
Notice that what the lawyer is saying is untrue is a real narrow slice of the reporting and he didn’t say they were innocent of raping that girl. But an admirable attempt at salvaging JDL’s reputation in any case.
- Merkin
- Posts: 43290
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 10:31 am
- Reputation: 1563
- Location: UA basketball smells like....victory
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
NVM
Last edited by Merkin on Mon Jul 24, 2023 9:58 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- EastCoastCat
- Posts: 6524
- Joined: Fri Jun 06, 2014 11:25 am
- Reputation: 1949
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
Or a family receiving $10M from foreign nationals and their related companies for doing nothing too. Totally agree.
But we digress...
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
Not a good statement. To typical of cover-up strategy.EastCoastCat wrote: ↑Fri May 12, 2023 7:43 amOr a family receiving $10M from foreign nationals and their related companies for doing nothing too. Totally agree.
But we digress...
I like to see the apology (apologies?). If anything, supporters of de Laura should be showing evidence of "good citizenship" since then, genuine remorse (for whatever happened), and forthright statements about respect of women and support for recovery...
Of course, assuming any of that exists.
Once lawyers finish their specific legal job, they should bow the F out!!!
IMNSHO, this will more likely aggravate the situation rather than work towards resolution...
“If you have the choice between humble and cocky, go with cocky. There's always time to be humble later, once you've been proven horrendously, irrevocably wrong.”
― Kinky Friedman
― Kinky Friedman
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
pc in NM wrote: ↑Fri May 12, 2023 8:09 amNot a good statement. To typical of cover-up strategy.EastCoastCat wrote: ↑Fri May 12, 2023 7:43 amOr a family receiving $10M from foreign nationals and their related companies for doing nothing too. Totally agree.
But we digress...
I like to see the apology (apologies?). If anything, supporters of de Laura should be showing evidence of "good citizenship" since then, genuine remorse (for whatever happened), and forthright statements about respect of women and support for recovery...
Of course, assuming any of that exists.
Once lawyers finish their specific legal job, they should STFU!!!
IMNSHO, this will more likely aggravate the situation rather than work towards resolution...
“If you have the choice between humble and cocky, go with cocky. There's always time to be humble later, once you've been proven horrendously, irrevocably wrong.”
― Kinky Friedman
― Kinky Friedman
- EastCoastCat
- Posts: 6524
- Joined: Fri Jun 06, 2014 11:25 am
- Reputation: 1949
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
Like everything going on today everyone has taken their position on the topic and probably won't budge with this statement coming out.
Whatever the truth is I still don't see this reflecting well on our program.
Whatever the truth is I still don't see this reflecting well on our program.
- Merkin
- Posts: 43290
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 10:31 am
- Reputation: 1563
- Location: UA basketball smells like....victory
Re: 7 Jayden de Laura
NVM
Last edited by Merkin on Mon Jul 24, 2023 9:57 pm, edited 1 time in total.